Showing posts with label Currency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Currency. Show all posts

Sunday, 2 April 2017

The blue passport farce


The results of a recent YouGov poll about what people think the government should do in post-Brexit Britain creates a horrifying picture of the delusional post-Brexit fantasy land that huge numbers of Brexiters are anticipating.

A post-Brexit fantasy land where the colour of your passport cover is of more importance than the rights that your passport gives you!

What Brexiters want


The single most popular thing Brexiters want to bring back is the death penalty. It's been proven time and again that the death penalty doesn't act as a deterrent (life sentences are much more of a punishment, that's why mass murderers and the like so often try to commit suicide in jail). It's also well understood that the death penalty creates appalling miscarriages of justice (many of the people executed by the British state during the 20th Century have had their convictions posthumously overturned). Despite all of the evidence an astounding 53% of Brexiters want the death penalty brought back.

42% of Brexiters say they want corporal punishment in schools brought back too, meaning that one of their top priorities for Brexit Britain is to give teachers the right to physically assault our children!

48% of Brexiters want things to bring back pounds and ounces. Firstly they never went away, it's always been legal to sell stuff in pounds and ounces in the UK as long as you include the metric conversion too. Secondly imperial measures are a ridiculously over-complicated anachronism. If Brexiters think that grams and kilograms are foreign unpatriotic muck they can avoid using them, but forcing the rest of us to abandon the sensible and easy to use metric measuring system so that we can all start dividing stuff by 14 and 16 again is ridiculous nonsense.

Blue passports


After pining for the return of the death sentence, the second most popular thing on the Brexiter wishlist is for the return of blue passports. 52% of Brexiters see this as one of the main priorities for Brexit Britain!

The hard-right tabloids and Eurosceptic MPs have fed into this nostalgic delusion that the colour of our passports is of such significance whatever and millions of Brexiters have lapped it up.

The Tory MP Andrew Rossindell has gone as far as describing the current burgundy passport as a "humiliation" and claiming that once the blue passport returns the British people "can once again feel pride and self-confidence in their own nationality when travelling"!

The idiocy of this stance is astounding. The current UK passport gives us all the right to travel, and work, and study, and retire in any of 27 nations across Europe. If the Tories insist on scrapping freedom of movement then it's obvious that the post-Brexit passport will not provide all of these rights, no matter what colour the cover is.

Over half of Brexiters are more bothered about the colour of their passport cover than they are about the fact that Brexit is going to significantly diminish the value of it!

The reintroduction of blue passports won't be a source of "pride and self-confidence" at all, it will be a constant visual reminder of the fact that the British passport has been reduced in value and rendered inferior to the Irish one.

Perspective

  • Since the Brexit vote the pound has collapsed in value and not recovered. Millions of Brits living abroad suffered an instant 15% devaluation of their money, but people in the UK are much more insulated from the fact they're 15% poorer than they were before because price inflation takes time to seep through. It only becomes glaringly obvious that we're all poorer when we go on holiday and notice the shockingly poor exchange rates.
  • Various sectors of the UK economy are warning of severe Brexit-related recruitment crises. The services and agricultural sectors are particularly worried.
  • Scotland is preparing to remove itself (and all of its oilfields and enormous renewable energy capacity) from the Brexit car crash.
But screw all that stuff eh chaps. Our passports are going to be blue again, and that's the fundamentally important thing. Hooray for the magnificent benefits of Brexit! 

 Another Angry Voice  is a "Pay As You Feel" website. You can have access to all of my work for free, or you can choose to make a small donation to help me keep writing. The choice is entirely yours.




OR

Tuesday, 16 September 2014

Salmond has "no plan B"? The Westminster establishment are having a laugh


One of the most pervasive propaganda narratives utilised by the Westminster establishment and their allies in the mainstream corporate media in their campaign to keep Scotland under Westminster control is the oft repeated "No Plan B" accusation made against the SNP leader Alex Salmond.

The "No Plan B"  accusations came about because Alex Salmond refused to give in to the economically risky hardball tactics used by the Westminster establishment. Salmond insists that his plan for Scotland is that they will continue using the Pound as currency, whilst George Osborne has insisted that that an independent Scotland will lose the Pound, reinforced through constant reiteration of statements like "No ifs, no buts, we will not share the pound if Scotland separates from the UK".

   This hardline stance from Westminster is extraordinarily risky because it creates a lot of economic uncertainty. In fact it actually actually relies on the fear of economic uncertainty frightening people away from voting for Scottish independence. Economic uncertainty is extremely bad because it damages market confidence, causes risk aversion and capital flight, and is an important causal factor in the development of economic crises.

The best course of action from an economic perspective would have been for both sides to agree a fixed-term currency union in order to maintain economic stability during the process of constitutional separation, should Scotland vote for self-determination. The Westminster establishment simply couldn't agree to this kind of pragmatic solution because they felt that they needed to frighten the Scottish people with economic uncertainty in order to win the debate. In my view this decision to put a political propaganda narrative above the stability of the economies on either side of the border just goes to show how terribly unfit to rule the Westminster establishment really are.

Another huge hole in the 
"No Plan B" propaganda narrative is that Alistair Darling (the leader of the Better Together campaign) has publicly admitted the truth, that there is absolutely nothing the Westminster establishment can do to stop an independent Scotland from using the pound. 

As far as I'm concerned Alex Salmond's plan to have a long-term currency union between Scotland and the UK is not a good one. You only have to look at the disastrous economic consequences of the Argentine Peso-US Dollar currency peg, or the Eurozone crisis, to get an idea of why currency unions are risky.However, since Alex Salmond is the democratically elected head of Scotland and I'm not, he's the one making the plans (until 2016 that is).

If Scotland does achieve independence, and the Westminster establishment continue to play their incredibly risky game of hardball, Salmond has a number of other options to pursue, plans B through to F if you like (I prefer option E or F by the way).

  • Plan A: Currency union with the UK
  • Plan B: No currency union, but use the Pound anyway
  • Plan C: Use the Euro
  • Plan D: Launch a Scottish currency pegged to the value of the Pound or the Euro
  • Plan E: Launch a free floating Scottish currency
  • Plan F: Launch an innovative new kind of currency (a Scottish cryptocoin perhaps)
Now that we've established that there are many options open to Alex Salmond, or whoever might succeed him as leader of an independent Scotland, we'll look at the factor that makes the "No Plan B" propaganda narrative of the Westminster establishment so incredibly hypocritical.

In the week before the Scottish referendum David Cameron's official spokesperson admitted that the government has made no contingency plans at all should the people of Scotland vote for self-determination, and excused this extraordinary admission of complacency with the claim that "The government’s entire focus is on making the case for the UK staying together".

The Westminster establishment have publicly stated that they have
 "No Plan B"  should the people of Scotland defy them and vote for self-determination. The only thing they're prepared to publicly commit to in regards to an independent Scotland is their plan to deny Scotland use of the Pound, no matter what the economic consequences either side of the border!

Of course there is the possibility that they have drawn up secret contingency plans, but that they're lying to the public about it. However to chastise a political opponent for having 
"No Plan B"  whilst publicly stating that they themselves have "No Plan B"  is a ludicrously hypocritical stance.

I suppose the only way that we get to find out whether David Cameron's official spokesperson was blatantly lying, or if the Westminster establishment really are that breathtakingly complacent that they actually haven't drawn up any contingency plans at all, is for the Scottish people to vote Yes.


 Another Angry Voice  is a not-for-profit page which generates absolutely no revenue from advertising and accepts no money from corporate or political interests. The only sources of income for  Another Angry Voice  are small donations from people who see some value in my work. If you appreciate my efforts and you could afford to make a donation, it would be massively appreciated.


Flattr this




MORE ARTICLES FROM
 ANOTHER ANGRY VOICE 
         
Scottish independence and uncertainty
           
Scottish independence: We don't need your pity
                     
A letter to Scottish voters
       

Why the Unionist campaign is falling apart
                             
The "unpatriotic left" fallacy 
                                         
How Labour dropped the ball on Scottish independence
                          
Scottish independence: Hope against Fear
                
Asset stripping "bankrupt" Britain with Gideon & Dave
                      
The Tory ideological mission
                                
Margaret Thatcher's toxic neoliberal legacies
  



Monday, 15 September 2014

Scottish independence, a tale of hope against fear


In just a few days the people of Scotland will go to the polls to decide the future of their nation.

I'm not Scottish, I'm a Yorkshireman, and I don't live in Scotland. However I have written extensively about the Scottish independence referendum because I passionately believe that Scotland could be a better country if they had a smaller, more democratic and more accountable government, instead of being ruled over by the corrupt, self-serving and unaccountable Westminster establishment down in London.


A message of hope

The Yes campaign has attracted support from all kinds of people, from all different walks of life, and all different political persuasions. In my view the one thing that unifies them all is the idea that an independent Scotland has the potential to do things better. It's the hope of a working to create a better Scotland.

This hope for a better Scotland isn't just an idle optimistic fantasy because there is already plenty of evidence that a better Scotland can be achieved through the localisation of political power. Thanks to the existence of the Scottish parliament, access to university education in Scotland hasn't been commodified and financialised as it has been in the rest of the UK. Scottish students from poor and ordinary backgrounds aren't forced to assume huge debts, which are then repayed through a 9% aspiration tax on their disposable income, that for millions will not be payed off, even through an entire lifetime of work.

Thanks to the devolution of power over the NHS and the education system, Scotland has remained immune to the waves of Tory ideological privatisations that have seen £1.5 billion in NHS contracts handed out to Tory party donors, and over 3,000 English schools simply given away to unaccountable private sector interests.

The success of an independent Scotland is by no means guaranteed. If the Yes campaign wins the vote, the people of Scotland can't just sit back and relax at a job well done, It is absolutely vital that the amazing spirit of political engagement that has been awoken by the independence debate is kept alive.

In order for an independent Scotland to "do things better" the ordinary people of Scotland will have to engage in the process of constitutional renewal, work hard to hold their politicians to account, and work together to make sure that the issues that are important to them stay at the forefront of the political agenda.

A Yes vote isn't the objective in itself. The real objective is for the people of Scotland to give themselves the opportunity to hold the Scottish government to account, in a way that has been simply impossible to do through the corrupt and antiquated political system that has allowed the Westminster establishment to ruthlessly enforce their agenda of austerity and privatisation against the will of the vast majority of the population.

A message of fear

The No campaign has promoted a very different message, a message based around the basic animal instinct of fear. The Westminster establishment and their allies in the mainstream media have bombarded the public with one scare story after another.

The No campaign has constantly fearmongered about how Scottish oil is going to dry up, even though the experts are divided on how many billions of barrels remain untapped, and how many hundreds of billions of pounds that will be worth to the Scottish economy. The only consensus between the experts in the oil industry over how much oil remains seems to be that the figures publicised by George Osborne's Office for Budget Responsibility are extraordinary under-estimates.

The No campaign has fearmongered about Scotland not being able to defend itself. Who could forget the former Secretary of State for Scotland George Robertson (who now occupies a seat in the anti-democratic House of Lords) demeaning his own country by referring to it as "a minor entity in the north of Britain" as he tried to fearmonger about the threat of Islamist extremism to an independent Scotland. In my view the threat of Islamist extremism in Scotland would be severely diminished if future governments of the nation avoid participation in the invasion and occupation of predominantly Muslim countries.

The No campaign has fearmongered about the major banks relocating their headquarters to London, presumably because they assume that the Scottish public are such a bunch of feckless halfwits that they'll have completely forgotten that it was the banks that created the economic crisis in the first place with their massive fraud schemes and their incredible binge of reckless unregulated gambling. 
Even if some of the banks do relocate their headquarters, they can't just take all of their jobs and tax revenues with them. Taxes on financial services provided in an independent Scotland would go to the Scottish government*, no matter where the official headquarters of the bank that provides them. 

RBS, which is 82% owned by the taxpayer, threatening to leave an independent Scotland in order to try to influence the outcome of the referendum just goes to show the desperation of the Westminster establishment. What on earth is a publicly owned bank doing trying to interfere with a public vote? 

Even though the No campaign has been losing ground in the debate as the referendum has drawn nearer, they have stubbornly refused to change tack. And in the final week, ludicrous stories were circulated about how the supermarkets would impose massive price rises in an independent Scotland. Fortunately there was someone with the good sense to actually write to the supermarkets and ask them. The response from all four of the supermarket giants was the same; that they have no plans at all to raise prices in an independent Scotland.

It beggars belief that the leaders of Better Together can't see that their fearmongering has been driving undecided people into the arms of the Yes camp, and with just days to go before the vote they still haven't tried to present anything resembling a coherent positive case for continued union. All they seem capable of doing is pressurising their corporate buddies into talking down the prospects for an Independent Scotland in order to constantly snipe that "Scotland just won't be able to hack it on it's own". If I was a Unionist (which I'm not) I'd be utterly dismayed with the risible Better Together campaign and the hopelessly complacent debating strategies they've used.

Perhaps the biggest fearmongering campaign of all is the insistence by the Westminster establishment that Scotland will not be able to use the Pound, which is of course, as Alistair Darling himself admits, an impossible threat. Scotland can use the Pound because it is a freely tradeable currency. The only thing that the Westminster establishment can do in reality is to rule out a formal currency union between Scotland and the remainder of the UK.

In my view a long-term currency union wouldn't be in the interests of an independent Scotland anyway (look at the Argentina-US pegged currency union and the Eurozone), however a temporary fixed-term currency union in order to ensure economic stability during the process of constitutional separation would have been by far the most pragmatic option from an economic perspective, because economic uncertainty leads to economic instability (risk aversion, market panics and the development of economic crises).

Such a short term currency agreement would have mitigated some of the worst effects of economic uncertainly on either side of the border during the constitutional separation, however such a pragmatic stance was never going to be adopted by the Westminster establishment because uncertainty over the future currency of Scotland is one of the pillars of their anti-independence propaganda campaign. The fact that the Westminster establishment would put a political propaganda narrative above the stability of the economies on either side of the border just goes to show how terribly unfit to rule they really are.

Conclusion

I know it's not possible to imagine that all pro-Independence people are hopeful optimists, nor to tar all anti-independence people as cynical and fearful pessimists, because that would be the kind of naive absolutist thinking I so often argue against in my work. However, in my view it is fair to describe that the propaganda strategies employed by the two campaigns as a battle between hope and fear.

The spirit of hope must be stronger than fear, because what optimism can we have for the future if, even after the amazing political reawakening of Scotland, the majority still choose fear over hope? What optimism can we possibly have for the future if the positive, complex and very human spirit of hope can be defeated by the negative, simplistic and animalistic sensation of fear?

I'm hoping that later this week I'll be able to celebrate the rebirth of the Scottish nation, and drink heartily to the future of Scotland, rather than having to lament that the people of Scotland passed up the greatest opportunity of their lifetimes to effect real political change because they allowed the animal instinct of fear to overpower the human spirit of hope.


 Another Angry Voice  is a not-for-profit page which generates absolutely no revenue from advertising and accepts no money from corporate or political interests. The only sources of income for  Another Angry Voice  are small donations from people who see some value in my work. If you appreciate my efforts and you could afford to make a donation, it would be massively appreciated.


Flattr this

* As long as the Scottish people are prepared to pressurise the Scottish government into clamping down on tax-dodging.




MORE ARTICLES FROM
 ANOTHER ANGRY VOICE 
         
How the anti-independence campaign is falling apart
        
Scottish independence and uncertainty
           
Scottish independence, vote Yes because we don't need your pity
                     
A letter to Scottish voters
       

Scottish independence and the complacency of the Westminster establishment
                             
The Tory vandalism of the education system
                                         
Who is to blame for the economic crisis?
                          
"Bedroom Tax" - tax the poor to subsidise the rich
                
Asset stripping "bankrupt" Britain with Gideon & Dave
                      



Tuesday, 9 September 2014

Why the pro-unionist campaign is falling apart


The UK establishment has united together in a desperate effort to protect London rule over Scotland. This collaboration is obvious both in the fact that the three Westminster establishment parties are happy to put aside their differences (as small as they are these days) and join forces in opposition to greater autonomy for Scotland, and from the way that the corporate mainstream media has continued to present desperately slanted, and often outright biased analysis.

The problem for the establishment powers is not that they don't have the power to spread their message, the constant pro-union bias of the mainstream media is testament to the fact they do. The problem is that the message that they have been trying to spread is so hopeless.

In this article I'm going to explore the tactical ineptness of the pro-Union campaign under four main headings.

A reckless all-or-nothing gamble

The first, and probably the biggest mistake from the no camp was David Cameron's absurd decision to hold a gun to the heads of the Scottish electorate in a "with us or against us" binary choice by leaving the Devo Max option off the Independence ballot.

The evidence is clear that Devo Max was actually the preferred option of the Scottish electorate, but Cameron ruled it out in order to fight a battle over the two less popular options because he'd rather risk the entire constitutional future of the United Kingdom, than give the people of Scotland the level of autonomy they actually wanted.

The decision to rule out Devo Max was an absolute gift to Alex Salmond and the Scottish National Party. Instead of trying to make a very difficult argument that the people of Scotland should choose full independence over remaining in the Union but gaining autonomy over pretty much everything apart from defence and foreign policy, he was left with a very easy juxtaposition of full independence against the unacceptable status quo of having the corrupt and complacent Westminster establishment continue to rule over the lives of Scottish people with impunity.

David Cameron's gamble with the constitutional future of the United Kingdom was a shocking display of arrogance and complacency. The fact that he would rather take such a ridiculous gamble than voluntarily offer people the powers they wanted, just goes to show how unfit he is to rule over Scotland, or anyone at all.

Incessant fearmongering


Fear is one of the most powerful human emotions, and it has been known since antiquity that such powerful emotions are strong motivators. There was obviously a decision made by the political establishment to run a predominantly negative fear based campaign against the concept of Scottish independence.

Some of the fearmongering from the No camp has been demeaning and absolutely ridiculous. From publicising absurd underestimates about how much Scottish oil is left, to blatant fearmongering about how an independent Scotland would be too insignificant to protect itself from global terrorism, "too poor, too wee, too stupid" has been a constant theme of the No campaign.

As the Yes vote has gradually surged, and the polls have shown a strong and sustained shift towards Yes, the Westminster establishment have decided to ramp up the fearmongering rhetoric rather than try to change the message that is clearly turning so many people against them.

Thus in the last weeks before the referendum, we've had George Robertson (a true an establishment insider as there's ever been) demeaning his own country as "a minor entity in the north of Britain" during a speech in which he was fearmongering about the rise of ISIS in Syria and Iraq*, and we've had the billionaire oil man Ian Wood (another establishment insider) talking down the size of Scotland's oil reserves and fearmongering about the future of Scottish infrastructure and services , despite having led a review into the future of Scottish oil just a few months previously which had come up with much higher estimates.


The decision to run an overwhelmingly negative campaign and repeatedly telling the Scottish electorate that they are "too poor, too wee, too stupid" was another humongous tactical error, which allowed the Yes campaign to portray the independence debate as "a message of hope against a message of fear".

A game of dangerous economic brinkmanship

One of the most pervasive fear narratives utilised by the No camp is the insistence that an independent Scotland will lose the Pound, reinforced through constant reiteration of statements like "No ifs, no buts, we will not share the pound if Scotland separates from the UK" from the Chancellor George Osborne.

Fearmongering over the future of the national currency is a classic example of putting the dissemination of a propaganda narrative way above the best interests of the economy. It's understandable why the establishment developed this strategy, because to form any kind of agreement with Alex Salmond and the Yes campaign over the future currency of an independent Scotland could have been seen as pre-negotiating a successful campaign for independence, and it would have cost the no camp one of their best fearmongering strategies into the bargain. However the consequence of the hardline stance against any kind of currency union (short-term or long-term) is now causing economic panic due to the uncertainty over the future currency of Scotland, the value of Sterling, the valuation of Scottish businesses, and innumerable trade implications. This panic is getting so bad that the financial analysts and mainstream press have begun running stories of how independence could cause a devastating "Eurozone-style economic crisis".

All of this economic uncertainty and the consequential risk aversion and potential of market panics could easily have been avoided had both sides of the debate agreed on a short-term currency union during the process of constitutional separation, should it come to pass. Had it been clear to the markets that an independent Scotland would keep the Pound for a predetermined period (five years, ten years) during the separation process, much of this economically damaging uncertainty could have been avoided.

In playing a dangerous game of economic brinkmanship over the future stability of the UK and Scottish economies, George Osborne and the establishment figures who devised this "you ain't having the pound" narrative have shown their willingness to blatantly ignore the economic best interests of both economies in order to do little more than try to intimidate the Scottish electorate. Such a hardline stance over the future of the Pound is an appallingly risky strategy, and should a vote for independence actually trigger an economic crisis, the people who devised this deliberate policy of promoting fear and economic uncertainty should be held accountable for their actions.

Undeliverable last minute promises


The opinion polls have been showing a gradual increase in the pro-Independence vote, but this didn't stop the establishment going into full panic mode when the first big poll predicted a win for the Yes camp.

That the political establishment and the mainstream press are in panic mode is unquestionable. Witness the absurd decision of the three leaders of the Westminster establishment parties to abandon the weekly spectacle that is Prime Minister's Questions, in order to head up to Scotland in a desperate attempt to shore up the failing pro-Union campaign, and also the talk of "new powers" for Scotland with less than two weeks to go before the referendum date.

The problem with the three establishment leaders making a haphazard dash for Scotland, is that two of them (Clegg and Cameron) are politically toxic in the eyes of the Scottish electorate, and the other is at best a bloody huge disappointment, not least because of his unfathomable decision to share a political platform with the other two in the first place. These three showing up in Scotland is more likely to boost the Yes campaign by reminding the Scottish electorate how bloody awful the Westminster establishment is, rather than turn the tide back towards the pro-Unionist camp.

The mainstream media has been awash with stories of how the political parties are "scrambling" to offer Scotland "new powers". If any politicians do attempt to offer new last-minute changes to the powers on offer to Scotland (after tens of thousands of people have already sent their postal ballots), they would clearly be in breech of Electoral Commission guidelines (since 
the Purdah rules came into force, government departments have been barred from announcing new policies or initiatives), and would surely be guilty of prejudicing the referendum and forcing a new one.

In my view the sheer inaccuracy of the mainstream press coverage referencing the scramble to offer these "new powers" is deeply misleading (see footnotes for examples). Even though both are largely ineffectual and discredited regulators, I'd expect a fair few complaints to the Press Complaints Commission and the Electoral Commission over such misleading, and potentially prejudicial coverage.

Conclusion

Time will tell whether the pro-Union campaign was run badly enough to drive Scotland out of the Union (not much time though, with the referendum due just nine days after the publication of this article).

Whatever the case, the pro-Union campaign has been a disaster. The three main establishment parties (Labour, Conservatives and Lib Dems) aligned against the SNP and a few minor players like the Scottish Greens and the Scottish Socialist Party, and virtually the entire mainstream media aligned against the Sunday Herald, a few independent websites like Wings Over Scotland and a some celebrity Twitter accounts (Frankie Boyle, Irvine Welsh, Kevin Bridges ...) should have ensured an absolute rout for the No campaign.

With the odds stacked so ridiculously in their favour like this, anything but a landslide victory for No would represent a very poorly fought campaign indeed.

In my view the failure of the Unionist campaign can once again be apportioned to establishment complacency. Perhaps they imagined that they couldn't loose if they had had the entire mainstream media on their side, twisting every story to suit the Unionist agenda. However what this completely unbalanced media situation resulted in was a massive grass roots campaign from the Yes camp. If the No camp were going to completely dominate the media, they the Yes camp would dominate in the streets of Scotland. In my view the surge in support for Yes is down to the face-to-face communication that comes of political activism and direct engagement.

Hopefully if Scotland does achieve independence, these political activists and grass roots campaigns won't just sit back an relax after a job well done, they'll realise that "people power" and political activism really can overcome the collective might of the political establishment, the mainstream media and countless corporate interests. Once they have proven this power to themselves, the people of Scotland will have no excuse for not holding the future government of Scotland to account and demanding the kinds of progressive social change Scotland so badly needs after decades of neglect by the Westminster establishment.


 Another Angry Voice  is a not-for-profit page which generates absolutely no revenue from advertising and accepts no money from corporate or political interests. The only sources of income for  Another Angry Voice  are small donations from people who see some value in my work. If you appreciate my efforts and you could afford to make a donation, it would be massively appreciated.


Flattr this

* It is worth considering that the rise of Isis is something that probably never would have happened anyway without a. the invasion and occupation of Iraq, b. the West's interference in the Syrian civil war or c. the west's support for the financial backers of ISIS in Saudi Arabia and the UAE.

A non-exhaustive list of misleading "New Powers" coverage in the mainstream media:

The Guardian: "Westminster leaders will on Monday scramble to agree an offer of more powers to Scotland if it remains within the union in an effort to prevent a yes vote in next week's referendum." - which clearly implies that such powers have not already been agreed before purdah.

New Statesman: "
Westminster prepares to offer further powers to Scotland - but is it too little, too late?" - an extremely misleading headline, unless of course the establishment parties actually intend to break the electoral rules and invalidate the referendum!

Express Tribune: "
The British government scrambled Sunday to pledge greater autonomy for Scotland, after a poll put the pro-independence camp ahead just 11 days before the referendum on separation." - clearly implies a causation between the poll result and the offer of new powers.

Wall Street Journal: "
The British government promised new powers for Scotland in areas including taxes, spending and welfare if it votes to remain in the U.K. after a weekend opinion poll showed a surprising surge in support for Scottish independence." - again implying a non existent causation




MORE ARTICLES FROM
 ANOTHER ANGRY VOICE 
         
Reasons Scotland should vote Yes - 1: Uncertainty
           
Reasons Scotland should vote Yes - 2: We don't need your pity
             
  
Reasons Scotland should vote Yes - 3: Westminster complacency

                     
A letter to Scottish voters
       

How Labour completely dropped the ball on Scottish independence
                             
The "unpatriotic left" fallacy 
                          
"Bedroom Tax" - tax the poor to subsidise the rich
                
Asset stripping "bankrupt" Britain with Gideon & Dave
                      
The Tory ideological mission
                                
Margaret Thatcher's toxic neoliberal legacies
  



F

Wednesday, 21 May 2014

How the Green party is miles ahead of the game on monetary policy


For several years the group Positive Money has been running a public education drive to explain the way that money is created out of nothing by private banks, and then rented out to the public in interest bearing loans and mortgages, and why this kind of rentier system leads inevitably to irresolvable debt crises and vast speculative bubbles (here's a short video).

At first the establishment treated Positive Money dismissively, as if they were some kind of dangerous tinfoil hat wearing conspiracy peddlers, and tried to talk around the truth by harping on about things like capital requirements.

The Green party recognised the truth in what Positive Money have been highlighting, and in September 2013 they passed a motion to reform the monetary system by taking the power to create money away from the private banks and placing it in public hands.

This landmark motion didn't attract much attention at the time, this is hardly surprising since the mainstream economic press were hardly likely to pay much attention to what the Green party were up to. They should have been much more concerned with the fact that the Reinhart-Rogoff paper they had all lauded as concrete evidence that austerity was necessary was based on a hopelessly botched Excel spreadsheet that any proper science would have picked up in the process of peer review, and by the admission by the IMF that fiscal multipliers (government returns on investment) have been much, much higher since the global financial sector insolvency crisis (between 90p and £1.70 return per pound of investment, rather than the 50p return that austerity fetishists like George Osborne had assumed in their wildly over-optimistic economic projections).

Of the very little coverage about the Green party motion to reform the monetary system, the tone was negative. I actually agree with some of the criticism, because in my view their proposed solution isn't ideal, however to have recognised the problem and proposed a solution is far better than the political establishment (the Lib-Lab-Cons), which has carried on without any recognition of this glaring flaw in the way in which 97% of the money in the economy is created.


For the next six months Positive Money kept up their campaign to spread public awareness of the way money is created out of nothing by private banks and rented out to the public via interest bearing loans and mortgages, the political establishment continued to ignore the issue, and everyone pretty much forgot about the Greens.

Everything changed in March 2014 when the Bank of England released a document entitled Money Creation in the Modern Economy which admitted that "Whenever a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower’s bank account, thereby creating new money" and goes on to explain that banks actually loan out money whether or not they have enough in deposits in their reserves and then borrow the shortfall from the central bank to top up their reserves; thus showing that the Bank of England has accepted that Positive Money were absolutely right. This is probably the closest thing to a revolutionary paper released by the Bank of England in living memory, and has brought the subject of monetary policy to the fore.


This admission from the Bank of England shows that the Green party were well ahead of the game when they voted to reform monetary policy six months beforehand, and that the four other parties are way behind the game, with their heads stuck firmly in the outdated neoliberal textbooks that created the financial sector insolvency crisis in the first place.

That none of the other four parties have shown any interest in reforming the way money is created, in order to prevent the inflation of more speculative property bubbles (like the London bubble) is an illustration that they don't have any solutions. This is because they don't actually seem capable of recognising what the problem actually is, let alone offering anything resembling a solution.


The fact that the Labour party and the Liberal Democrats are offering no new solutions on monetary policy is bad enough (UKIP have been far too busy with their immigration fearmongering campaigns to look at the problem either) but the behaviour of George Osborne and the Tories has been frankly ludicrous. Not only is Osborne incapable of seeing the problem, he's busy pumping taxpayers' cash into the housing market (via Help to Buy and other such schemes) in order to further inflate the speculative property bubble caused by excessive and uncontrolled private sector money creation.

I don't think the Green party have got it exactly right on monetary policy, but they're way ahead of the Lib-Dems, Labour and UKIP by virtue of having actually recognised the problem, and they're double the distance ahead of George Osborne and the Tories because the Tories have actually introduced a load of policies which exacerbate the problem by using taxpayers' cash to pump up the market with false credit. This creation of false credit is their cack-handed solution to help people that have been priced out of the market due to the speculative bubble that has been fuelled by private sector money creation. Not only have they failed to see the root cause of the problem, but the solution they've devised simply makes the mess even worse.

To put this situation into a nice simple narrative, the Green party started running the race over six months ago (their running style isn't perfect, but they're moving along quite nicely and will hopefully really hit their stride soon), Labour and the Liberal Democrats are milling around at the start line unaware that the race has actually started, UKIP are off in the crowd somewhere hunting out immigrants, Muslims and homosexuals to intimidate, and George Osborne, like the clueless towel-folder that he is, has set off running in completely the wrong direction, going backwards around the track.


 Another Angry Voice  is a "Pay As You Feel" website. You can have access to all of my work for free, or you can choose to make a small donation to help me keep writing. The choice is entirely yours.




More articles from
 ANOTHER ANGRY VOICE 
       
UKIP is not an alternative
                 
 The mainstream media oligopoly
        
Why 73% of UKIP supporters should actually vote Green