Showing posts with label Financial Times. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Financial Times. Show all posts

Sunday, 3 March 2019

Right-wing ideologues are weaponising anti-Semitism to silence criticism of capitalism


People who follow Scottish politics may remember John McTernan as the unbelievably inept political strategist who managed to lose 40 of Labour's 41 Scottish seats in Westminster at the 2015 general election.

After masterminding the most catastrophic electoral collapse in British political history one would have thought that McTernan would be treated as the political joke that he is.

However the man with such boundless incompetence that he actually managed to kill the Labour Party in their Scottish heartlands is still routinely given mainstream media platforms and treated as if he's some kind of wise and knowledgeable political oracle, rather than the nonsense-spewing clown-like political figure that he actually is.

For some reason the normally reputable (but always right-leaning) Financial Times has given McTernan a platform to push his cartoonish political nonsense in a column entitled "Labour’s mistake is to believe there are no enemies to the left".

McTernan starts out with a number of obvious lies about Labour anti-Semitism claiming that anti-Semitism in the Labour ranks is "a recent phenomenon", which "coincides with the election of Jeremy Corbyn as leader".
 

The evidence is absolutely clear that support for anti-Semitic views have fallen dramatically since Jeremy Corbyn became party leader. This is almost certainly due to the massive influx of genuinely left-wing people into the party, many of them from the younger demographics who generally have way more socially liberal and progressive views than the older generations.

And as for the idea that anti-Semitism in Labour is a "recent phenomenon", how is it possible to explain how Labour's chief spin-doctor Alistair Campbell produced vile anti-Semitic attack posters in 2008? How is it possible to explain Campbell telling the journalists who uncovered the scandal to "fuck off and cover something important you twats"? And how is it possible to explain away the fact that the Blairite party leadership decided to take absolutely no action whatever to discipline him for either the anti-Semitic posters, or the abusive and 100% unapologetic reaction to the scandal?

After rambling on pretentiously for paragraph after paragraph McTernan eventually comes out with surely one of the most delusional and self-awareness deficient sentences ever to have featured in the Financial Times.

"Rhetoric about the 1 per cent and economic inequality has the same underlying theme [as anti-Semitic tropes] — a small group of very rich people who cleverly manipulate others to defend their interests. So anti-capitalism masks and normalises anti-Semitism"
This extraordinary effort to conflate legitimate criticisms of issues like capitalism and inequality with anti-Jewish bigotry is extraordinary on so many levels.

According to McTernan's warped worldview anyone who points out that just 8 men own the same wealth as half the world is being anti-Semitic!

Anyone who attempts to critique the excesses of the reckless over-financialised speculation frenzy that late stage capitalism has degenerated into is being anti-Semitic!

Anyone who points out that Tory austerity dogma has resulted in a vast transfer of wealth from the poor and ordinary to the mega-rich elitist class is being anti-Semitic!


Anyone who raises concerns about how mega-rich individuals and corporations routinely buy political influence and use their wealth to cynically manipulate others is being anti-Semitic!

The agenda here is obvious. It's an attempt to defend capitalism from any form of criticism by cynically equating the language of dissent against 
the hard-right economic status quo with unacceptable racist bigotry.

McTernan is hoping to construct a right-wing mindset where anyone who ever complains about the excesses of capitalism or the problem of rising inequality can be instantly dismissed as a racist bigot so as to permanently evade discussion of any of the actual issues they're trying to raise.

It's an attempt to create a right-wing version of political correctness whereby any attempt to ever question the capitalist system can be instantly shouted down and ignored as if it's nothing more than vile and unacceptable bigotry.

But the grotesque cynicism isn't even the worst thing about it. The worst thing is the vile self-righteousness that manifests as an absolute lack of self-awareness.


Even though he'd already proven himself to be an anti-Semitism denialist by whitewashing Labour's issues before 2015 when Blairites like him were running the show, McTernan imagines himself to be some kind of righteous white knight figure who is right, and just, and proper in his opposition to anti-Semitism. But his attempt to use anti-Semitism as a smokescreen to defend corporations and the mega-rich from any kind of systemic critique relies on an obvious anti-Semitic trope in itself.

In order to define any criticism of the greed, wealth-hoarding, manipulation, corruption, and influence-buying that goes on in late-stage capitalism as anti-Semitism, it's necessary to identify all of these issues as being inherently Jewish traits.

McTernan's line of thinking is that 1. Jews are greedy 2. the political left criticise greed: Therefore the political left are anti-Semites.

McTernan's hopeless effort to conflate criticism of the hard-right economic status quo with anti-Semitism is further demolished if we consider the fact that Jewish intellectuals from across the political spectrum have a long history of critiquing capitalism and inequality. Karl Marx was Jewish. Rosa Luxemburg was Jewish. Helen Suzman was Jewish. Hyman Minsky was Jewish. Robert Skidelsky is Jewish. Noam Chomsky is Jewish.

Are we expected to believe that all of these Jewish activists, academics and intellectuals are raving anti-Semites because they have critiqued capitalism and inequality?

Are we expected to believe that all left-wing Jewish people are 'self-hating Jews' simply because this obnoxious (non-Jewish) failure of a political strategist crudely conflates criticism of capitalism with anti-Semitism?

The problem with vile and conniving opportunists like McTernan is that they've realised accusations of anti-Semitism can be weaponised to discredit and silence their political opponents, but they're so base and crude that they end up actually spreading vile anti-Semitic tropes like 'greedy Jews' and 'self-hating Jews' around in their efforts to weaponise the issue for their own partisan purposes.

Conclusion

Criticism of the problems and excesses of late stage capitalism is not anti-Semitism.

John McTernan is cynically using the anti-Semitism issue to smear anyone who dares question what he considers to be the natural order of things.

However in order to weaponise anti-Semitism in this manner he's produced a vile article that stumbles through anti-Semitism denialism, invocation of the vile anti-Semitic 'greedy Jew' trope, to the implication that Jews who dare to ever critique capitalism or inequality must be 'self -hating Jews' who are engaging in anti-Semitism simply by raising their concerns about the state of the world.

Just like almost everything McTernan says, it's entirely useless in actually understanding the world around us, but it does serve to highlight the grotesque self-awareness deficient worldview that him and people like him occupy.

Is it any wonder Labour annihilated their own political heartlands in Scotland after their party became so dysfunctional that utterly repugnant hard-right ideologues like this ended up running the show?



 Another Angry Voice  is a "Pay As You Feel" website. You can have access to all of my work for free, or you can choose to make a small donation to help me keep writing. The choice is entirely yours.




OR

Friday, 12 May 2017

Another astounding display of pro-Tory bias from the BBC


You don't have to be an expert on politics to understand that BBC Question Time has become incredibly right-wing biased over the last decade or so.

Anyone who has watched the show in recent years will have noticed the way that the host David Dimbleby repeatedly hectors and interrupts Labour Party politicians and socially progressive panellists, whilst taking a much more lenient approach to right-wing politicians and commentators.


On Thursday May 11th the BBC upped the right-wing bias even further by planting an actual serving Tory Party councillor called Eric Holford in the audience, inviting him to ask the very first question of the show (in which he slagged off the Labour Party) and even letting him to make several comebacks against the panellists and legitimate members of the audience.

If the Tory councillor had used a fake name to cheat his way onto the show it might be understandable, but he didn't. He used his real name, under which he's stood as a Tory candidate in the Westminster elections in 2015, the Scottish parliament elections in 2016, and most recently the 2017 local government elections in Clydesdale where he won a council seat just a week previously in the local elections.

One week grinning his head off at winning a council seat for the Tory party, then the very next week pretending to be an ordinary member of the public in order to slag off the Labour Party on a national TV show!


The bias from the BBC is absolutely astounding. There's absolutely no way they should be allowing a serving Tory politician to masquerade as a member of the public in order to pose an extremely partisan question aimed at damaging his political opponents, but somehow they did, and somehow our supposedly neutral and non-partisan public sector broadcaster will get away with, it as they always do.

The question Eric Holford was invited to ask was a repetition of the agreed right-wing propaganda line that Labour's manifesto would "drag Britain back to the nightmare that was the 1970s".

Several of the panellists responded strongly against the planted Tory propaganda. The Labour shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry presented the general election as a choice between a better future where nurses no longer need to rely on food banks to survive, and young people can actually afford to buy a home, against more of the same from a Tory party that has run out of ideas.

The actor David Hayman and the SNP's Joanna Cherry were quite enthusiastic about the leaked Labour Party manifesto. Hayman said he genuinely welcomed the Labour manifesto as "exciting" because for the first time in ages it will give the people of the United Kingdom "a proper choice" and Cherry noted that the free university tuition manifesto pledge has been an SNP policy for years.


The Tory Home Office minister Ben Wallace responded to the question from his fellow Tory politician with an extraordinary ramble about how the UK is still £57 billion in deficit as if that's a good reason to vote Tory: "We said our policies would have totally eradicated the deficit by May 2015, but it's still £57 billion two years later - so vote for us!".

It's a sign of just how politically and economically illiterate this Ben Wallace guy must be to think that blibber-blabbering about "money trees" like an absolute half-wit and talking up your own massive economic failure is somehow a reason for people to vote for your party!


The Financial Times journalist Merryn Somerset Webb predictably took the Tory side putting on an exasperating display of political illiteracy as she used the Tories woefully inept efforts to reduce the deficit by slashing spending to the bone as a reason to criticise Labour's strategy of trying to resolve the problem in a different way through an investment led recovery.

"Austerity doesn't work, so an investment led recovery is a terrible idea, let's have more austerity" - 
If that's what passes for economic analysis at what used to be a very respectable publication, Britain really is as doomed to mediocrity as it seems.


At one point the host David Dimbleby even assisted the Tory plant Eric Holford in interrupting and shouting down a genuine member of the public who was complaining about the inflation in rail prices since privatisation!

Planting a Tory politician in the BBC Question Time audience didn't quite work to plan though because most of the panel, and most of the audience disagreed with his question, and the two panellists who actually agreed with him made themselves look like economically illiterate idiots in the process.

Sadly though, there are a lot of economic illiterates out there who actually enjoy hearing people blabbering on about "magic money trees" and "living within our means" like the worst kind of economically illiterate tabloid rote-learners, and telling everyone that Britain is too poor, and weak, and pathetic to deserve decent publicly owned railways and energy infrastructure like Germany, France or the Netherlands.

Doubtless the BBC will not face any repercussions for planting an actual serving Tory politician in the audience, allowing him to masquerade as a member of the public rather than identifying him for who he was, allowing him to have the very first question of the show in which he attacked an opposition party, and even assisting him in shouting down a genuine member of the public.


The BBC almost certainly won't suffer any consequences for this incident, but hopefully this brazenness of it will have at least opened a few more people's eyes to the shocking levels of pro-Tory bias at the BBC.

What we can do

  • Spread awareness of this outrageous incident by sharing this article and talking about this incident with people you know.


 Another Angry Voice  is a "Pay As You Feel" website. You can have access to all of my work for free, or you can choose to make a small donation to help me keep writing. The choice is entirely yours.




OR