Tuesday 9 February 2021

Andrew Neil's anti-woke "cancel culture" hypocrisy

The right-wing dinosaur Andrew Neil, who infamously spread deadly AIDS misinformation into the 1990s and let his mate Boris Johnson get away with absolutely trashing any pretence at BBC impartiality by dodging the partisan grilling he administered to every other party leader in the 2019 election, has completely given the game away about how the right-wing corporate media operates.

He's busy launching a new news channel called GB News, which will operate as another propaganda vehicle for hard-right billionaires; a kind of Fox News for Britain intent on pushing as many right-wing figures and propaganda talking points into the national political discourse as possible.

Neil has repeatedly described how this new channel is going to be "anti-woke", and many people have pointed out to him that since "woke" is defined as:

1. Well informed

2. Alert to injustice in society, especially racism

The logical conclusion is that his new propaganda venture on behalf of Rupert Murdoch is going to ensure that their audience are not well informed, and not alert to injustice and racism.

Neil's comeback to this argument is absolutely telling. He has openly declared on Twitter that "the original definition of woke is out of date" and that it now means a form of cancel culture that seeks to "close down ideas and people with which it disagrees".

The interesting thing about this claimed fundamental change in the fundamental meaning of "woke" comes when we think about who has orchestrated this complete redefinition of the term.

Anyone who cares about the meaning and origins of words will know that the term "woke" originates from the African-American vernacular English to "stay woke", which means staying awake to issues like injustice and systemic racism.

The mainstream media, especially in Britain, have deliberately changed this meaning to turn it into a pejorative term they use to sneer at any left-wing or socially progressive cause, not just anti-racism, feminism, but LGBT rights, environmental campaigns, and basically anything concerned with combating injustice.

So we've got black people in the United States developing a specific term to describe the important aspect of their lives that is to do with maintaining awareness of injustice, racism, and systemic persecution ... and then we've got wealthy, white, right-wing polemicists like Andrew Neil declaring that the original black meaning of the term is defunct and incorrect, and that it now refers to a form of "cancel culture" which seeks to silence and erase people and ideas with which it disagrees.

Once we consider the origins of the term, the hypocrisy of Andrew Neil cancelling the original meaning and replacing it with a pejorative redefinition becomes absolutely obvious.

By deliberately redefining the term to mean something else, and declaring the original meaning cancelled, Andrew Neil and his ilk are guilty of exactly the kind of fanatical "cancel culture" extremism they accuse others of.

They're seeking to cancel the proper meaning and silence the black voices who use the term in its original and intended way, in order to overwrite it with a new and deeply pejorative definition.

If anyone is engaging in "cancel culture" it's Andrew Neil, who is so obsessed with opposing those who seek to keep people informed about injustice and racism, that he's deliberately redefining their vocabulary to make it an insulting caricature of its proper and original meaning.

How much more "cancel culture" can you get than cancelling the meaning of words to replace them with your own insulting redefinition?

This blunder from Neil goes further than mere hypocrisy though, it gives the game away about the Orwellian language-redefining tactics that right-wing propagandists have been using for decades.

Take the way terms like "socialism" and "capitalism" are used across the corporate media.

The actual meaning of "socialism" is a specific kind of economic organisation in which public infrastructure and services are publicly owned. The more communal ownership there is in a society, the more socialist it is.

But if you read the Murdoch propaganda rags, or any of the other corporate media, "socialism" is given an absurd caricature meaning, like 'spending other people's money', or 'handouts to the idle'.

It doesn't help their cause to apply the proper meaning of socialism, because the vast majority of people tend to agree that things like health, education, emergency services, water, energy, and transport should indeed be run as not-for-profit public services, so they invent their own pejorative meaning to make it look silly and ridiculous instead.

The same happens in reverse. They know perfectly well that "capitalism" refers to a specific form of economic organisation in which private interests control the infrastructure and services in order to extract as many unearned profits for themselves as possible.

But they continually refer to "capitalism" as if it's a mere synonym for "trade", or "doing business" as if private profiteering is the only conceivable form of economic organisation. 

It's conducive to their interests that people don't consider the inherently exploitative nature of capitalist profit extraction, and instead see capitalism as the only conceivable form of doing trade.

If capitalism is defined in this ridiculously broad way, it makes anyone opposing it seem like a deranged lunatic who wants humanity to descend to bartering for rabbit skins in caves, and that's exactly how the right-wing corporate media propagandists want it.

They continually and deliberately redefine words and phrases with new meanings that are more conducive to their own capitalist interests.

When there's an economic alternative to their favoured system, they redefine it to make it seem ludicrous.

When their favoured economic system comes under critique they give it such a generous new meaning that it would seem that only a maniac would oppose it.

And when black people create a new term to describe the ongoing process of staying alert to racism and injustice, they seek to erase it completely, and overwrite it with a pejorative new description.

So when Andrew Neil posts a Tweet chastising someone for using the original and intended meaning of "woke", and insists that his Orwellian caricature of the meaning is now the only accepted meaning, he's not just being an absolute hypocrite by engaging in the very "cancel culture" tactics he decries, he's completely giving the game away about the insidious right-wing corporate media tactic of continually redefining the fundamental meaning of language in order to make it more conducive to the radically right-wing capitalist agenda that they're paid to promote.


 Another Angry Voice  is a "Pay As You Feel" website. Access to my online writing will always remain free. If you see some value in what I do, please consider supporting my work with a small donation/subscription.



OR

19 comments:

Mighty Drunken said...

Good to see you post.

I came to the conclusion a year ago (longer?) that political debate across political divides is almost impossible.
When you use terms like; woke, capitalism, socialism they mean different things to different groups. So you will immediately start arguing across purposes and never came to an understanding.
This has being going on forever. Socialism and capitalism are made of many different components, some of which can be swapped in and out or varied. The words are too "big" and have too many different meanings.

I think a political philosopher needs to break these terms down in a particularly clever way so it is taught to everyone. So in the future we are able to discuss different political philosophies with each other.

Jason Matthews said...

"When their favoured economic system comes under critique they give it such a generous new meaning that it would seem that only a maniac would oppose it"

this made me think of MMT:

https://sovereignmoney.site/modern-money-theory-revisited

Mr. Magoo said...

I have never read a better example of the pot calling the kettle black! Andrew Neal may be a right-wing dinosaur, but you are a left-wing dinosaur. Real socialists have had to put up with Lenin and his disciples changing the meanings of the words "capitalism" and "socialism" for decades, but now we have to put up with reformists doing the same.

Capital is wealth that is invested into production/distribution in order to make more wealth. Therefore capital comes from (and can only come from) profit. Alas, capitalism is a global economic system obsessed with accumulating more & more & more profit.

When the coal mines were nationalised - a elderly woman went to one of them with a bucket to collect some free coal. The manager was tickled by this and asked to buy the coal from a shop. The purpose of that anecdote is to highlight the mistake left-wingers make: that WE are the state. States have always and will always represent class divided societies. State owned enterprises are just as committed to making profits as private enterprises. Nationalisation = state run capitalism.

Socialism is an international society in which the means of life (e.g. land; factories; railways) are commonly owned with the intention of producing/distributing wealth (i.e. useful things) to meet people's needs in harmony with nature.

https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/publications/education/

https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/pamphlet/socialist-principles-explained/

https://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/pamphlet/socialism-practical-alternative/


Unknown said...

You're both wrong . The original term was awake ie people awake to the corruption and deception in their govt and media . This was turned into woke , highjacked by the globalists for their controlled opposition .



JF said...

Good to see you posting again. Could we see more? I know you have been concentrating on other areas but i much prefer your blog. I dont agree with you on everything, in fact i often strongly disagree, but its always well worth reading.

Flyus Travels said...

I am very happy to read this content, Find the cheap flights tickets from Flyustravels
Direct flights from Delhi to USA
SFO to Vancouver flights
Non stop flights from USA to India

Anonymous said...

A fair bit wrong with the entire article but this stood out;
"The same happens in reverse. They know perfectly well that "capitalism" refers to a specific form of economic organisation in which private interests control the infrastructure and services in order to extract as many unearned profits for themselves as possible."

The dictionary definition has these described as MOSTLY free markets I should point out. The Etymology lies in the almost Night Watchmen style state from over two hundred years ago as the British Empire moved out of mercantile economics. How are the profits unearned exactly?

If a plumber who's invested capital to train himself and several apprentices in a plumbing company he owns alongside three other plumbers ... He's not earned this capital?

Genuinely curious.

Denis Francis said...

Hypocrisy is one of the worst things that spoils a human's personality and after world.

Adele Horin Discount Code

Jessica Dollar said...

Great, This Article is nice when i visit in this i like that even i share with my friends get a more knowledge, go and visit this is the my website.
amazon.com/mytv

amazon.com/mytv

amazon.com/mytv

El Dee said...

I remember the days of yore, when in school, being told of the different types of economy in the world. There was the 'Command Economy' in the USSR and there was 'Capitalism' in the USA but in the UK we had a 'Mixed Economy' which was considered the best. Not having the problems that the USSR suffered by trying to over regulate every part of the citizen's life and not having the US' problem where citizens had no protection from the vagaries of world economics.

Now the very terminology is abused and misunderstood as badly on our own TV as it is with the Americans who know little of the outside world..

Florence said...



I started on COPD Herbal treatment from Ultimate Health Home, the treatment worked incredibly for my lungs condition. I used the herbal treatment for almost 4 months, it reversed my COPD. My severe shortness of breath, dry cough, chest tightness gradually disappeared. Reach Ultimate Health Home via their website www.ultimatelifeclinic.com . I can breath much better and It feels comfortable!

Anonymous said...

action...reaction...solution
thesis...antithesis...synthesis
look over there...look over here...don't look behind you.

One day, people will no longer be fooled by the party tricks, carnival barkers, shell games, 3 card monte's, bait and switch and straw men that are routinely deployed to ensure we do not focus on the latest crime currently being committed against us by those we were told to trust.

The political left and right are particularly tedious instruments of division. Clearly both sides will say anything to gain power and then busily fulfill agendas that voters never asked for and in fact don't want because it is against their best interests, if they knew. They don't usually know because the media will ensure the important stuff remains hidden.

However, I do wonder how long it will take for people to fully realize that elections are rigged, leaders are chosen and their policy and legislation provided to them. Economies are run by the bankers and no matter which party is in power the interests of voters are forgotten faster than you lost all your freedoms after COVID.

Instead of dividing and arguing, as they intend us to, one day we will focus on the why until we determine those who benefit most and to whom accountability is a foreign concept. Then and only then will real positive change be possible.

kellsanna said...

I want to share to the world how Dr Maggi helped me cure my Herpes with his herbs i never believe it will work because i was introduce to him by my friend who was cure of herpes by Dr Maggi, so i will tell you all who is looking for a cure to their herpes, he took research before he could finally get the solution to it. thank God today am a beneficiary to these cure and i went back to the hospital after 7days of taking the herbs and i was tested negative, and he also cure any kind of  cancer without any surgery and he heal with natural herb. please i urge you to contact him now through his email address: drmaggiherbalhome@gmail.com or call/whatsApp him on +19179796387

kaylana said...



DR. OWO IS SUCH A GREAT MAN HE SAVE MY BROKEN MARRIAGE OF 9YEARS AND BROUGHT MY EX LOVING HUSBAND WHO WAS LATER WICKED TO ME AND MY CHILDREN BACK TO ME. MY HUSBAND DIVORCE ME AND LEFT THE KIDS TO MARRY ANOTHER LADY AND EVEN BOUGHT A HOUSE FOR THE LADY WHERE THEY LIVED. THEY MOVE OUT OF THE STATE FROM FLORIDA TO TEXAS AND HE NEVER CHECK UP ON US OR EVEN CARE ABOUT US ANY MORE. HE NEVER CALL NOR VISITS FOR A DAY. I HAVE TRIED TALKING TO HIS FRIENDS AND FAMILY MEMBER HE REFUSE TO LISTEN TO THEM ALL AND HE SAID IT OVER BETWEEN US. SO LUCKILY I GOT INTRODUCED TO DR. OWO BY A FRIEND WHO IS FAMILY IS ALWAYS LIVING IN HAPPINESS OVER 29YEARS OF THEIR MARRIAGE THEY NEVER HAD A MISUNDERSTANDING IN THERE HOME AND I ALWAYS WISH AND TELL HER IF MY FAMILY COULD BE HAPPY AS HER OWN SHE ALWAYS LAUGH AND REPLY ME WITH SMILE SAYING IT A BLESSING FROM GOD TO HER HOME. I KEEP ON FORCING HER TO TELL ME THE TRUTH AND LATER WITH TIME SHE INTRODUCE ME TO DR OWO AND I CONTACTED HIM THROUGH: DROWOHERBS@GMAIL.COM AND TELL HIM MY LIFE STORY THEN HE DID A MIRACULOUS AND MARVELOUS W0RK FOR ME BY CASTING A SPELL FOR ME THAT HELP ME BROUGHT BACK MY LOVING HUSBAND IT 6 YEARS NOW WE ARE LIVING HAPPILY AND MY HEART FULL OF JOY WITH THE KIDS DR OWO IS A GREAT MAN REACH HIM VIA WHATSAPP: +1 (717) 473-7391

Florence said...


I started on COPD Herbal treatment from Ultimate Life Clinic, the treatment worked incredibly for my lungs condition. I used the herbal treatment for almost 4 months, it reversed my COPD. My severe shortness of breath, dry cough, chest tightness gradually disappeared. Reach Ultimate Life Clinic via their website at www.ultimatelifeclinic.com . I can breath much better and It feels comfortable!

Mike Johnson said...

I advise you to write such news on instagram too. From here https://soclikes.com/buy-instagram-followers you can get followers for your instagram profile

ideasontrend said...


Thanks for sharing your precious time to create this post, it's so informative, and the content makes the post more interesting.really appreciated. Emily In Paris HBA Jacket

randa said...

GET YOUR EX LOVER BACK.VIA: dromokpo@gmail.com

This is my testimony of life that I will tell everyone. I have been married for 25 years Another woman had a spell to get away my lover from me, My husband left me and the children and we suffered for 2 years until I saw post about where this man Dr Omokpo has helped so many people recover their broken marriages and relationships to get their ex lovers back.
I decided to send him a message about my broken marriage and family, about how my husband left me and for him to help me bring back my loving husband home. This great man told me what to do and I followed him as he instructed. After 48 hours, as he told me, I saw a car enter the compound. I was shocked when I saw my husband. As I share my testimony with you my husband came back to me and the kids and that's why I'm so happy to introduce you all to meet this great man for solutions to your problems and bring your lover back to you and mend your broken marriage and relationship restored back to happiness as you wished. Contact this great man via: dromokpo@gmail.com

pg slot said...

ค่าย pg ทางเข้า มือถือ ใหม่ล่าสุด ความสนุกสนานร่าเริงรวมทั้งตื่นเต้นที่สุดในทางเกมคาสิโนออนไลน์ PG ปากทางเข้าโทรศัพท์มือถือใหม่ปัจจุบัน! ในปัจจุบันที่เทคโนโลยีก้าวล้ำขึ้นอย่างเร็ว